Cash Value Life Insurance vs. Buy Term and Invest the Difference Calculator
- and -

Investment Balance Estimator

This works well with the Life Insurance Needs Calculator, which is a separate program

Buy Term vs. Whole Life Demo Another Buy Term vs. VUL Comparison Program Directions
Buy term life insurance and invest the difference vs. whole life insurance calculator.

Site Information

Confused? It Makes Sense if You Start at the Home Page
 
Why We're Better

Money Calculator List and Prices

Discounts for Financial Planners

New Financial Planner Starter Kit

Professional Investment Portfolio Building Kit

How to Buy Money Calculator Software in General

Site Map

Site Info, History, Ordering Security, Privacy, FAQs

Questions About Life Insurance Software? Call (800) 658-1824 or Send E-mail

Free Downloads and Money Tools

Free Sample Comprehensive Financial Plan

Free Downloads, Investing Tips, and Tutorials

Financial Plan Module Demos

Links to Other Personal Finance Websites

The World's Best Free Retirement Calculator

Other Free Retirement Calculators

Free Bond Yield Calculator

Our Free Financial Calculators

Other Free Online Financial Calculators

Free Family Money Calculators

Free Real Estate Calculators

Free Debt Calculators

Free Investment Calculators

Free Tax Calculators

Free College Calculators

Free Insurance Calculators

Free Business Owner Calculators

Miscellaneous

How to Get Your Brokerage Account Data to Download into our Financial Tools

About Getting Financial Spreadsheet Approval by Broker Dealers and FINRA

Financial Plan Software Support

Financial Plan Integration

About Portfolio Management Software

About Using Monte Carlo with Personal Finance Software

About Portfolio Optimization

About Investment Risk Tolerance

About Using a Discount Broker to Manage Your Own Money (and about custodians for advisors)

About Long-Term Care Insurance Software

We did two buy term life insurance and invest the rest into mutual funds versus buying whole insurance comparisons (VUL) here. The first one uses an "average VUL" policy. The second one uses the same life insurance company we recommend on the variable annuity page. This makes the comparison as close as possible because one can't get a better VUL because of the no-load and minimal expense features. The bottom line is that even with the most efficient VUL policy on the planet, just buying a level term life insurance policy and investing the difference into no-load mutual funds (not even our recommended mutual funds) creams it (with over three times the money left at age 100).

This is only life insurance software you can buy that performs all of the following functions:

First it estimates, closer than anything else, the balance one would have accumulated in an investment, such as a mutual fund, given certain Real World input parameters such as:

º Amount of initial contribution.

º Amount of annual contributions. These can be different every year.

º Growth, or inflation, rate of annual contributions. This can be different every year.

º Rate of return. This can be different every year.

º Annual dividend yield.

º Annual realized capital gains rate (the amount of capital gains that are distributed to the shareholder, like in a mutual fund).

º Amount of unrealized capital gains that remain in the investment to grow and compound into the future.

º Tax basis after considering the above two things.

º Ordinary income tax rate.

º Capital gains tax rate.

º Dividend tax rate.

º Front-end and/or back-end loads or sales charges on investments.

º Management, 12b-1 fees, and other ongoing annual fees/expenses.

º Amount of withdrawals. These can be different every year.

º Years of withdrawals.

º Tax basis of withdrawals.

º Annual inflation rate of withdrawals.

Next it has an input section where the user inputs cash value life insurance information (such as VUL).

The user then inputs the comparable term insurance costs, which are deducted annually from the alternative investment account described above (mutual funds).

This information is then used to compare end-of-year market values of the regular (alternative) investment (less annual term costs) vs. the annual cash values in the life insurance policy.

The purpose of all of this is to estimate as closely as possible, how much money one would have accumulated in an investment such as a mutual fund after taking all of the Real World factors into account, such as taxes and expenses. Then it properly compares it to the insurance contract ledger.

If you're trying to decide whether to buy a cash value life insurance contract, or "buy term life insurance and invest the difference," this investment software will estimate the amount of money you will have left annually after a certain time horizon.

If you don't die, and you end up with $500,000 more in the alternative investment compared to the cash value life insurance contract, then you should have bought term life and invested the difference rather than buying the cash value whole life  contract.

Not only is this the only financial spreadsheet on the market that does this function, no personal finance software even comes close if you want a Real World scenario that takes everything into account in such great detail.

This is not only the best cash value insurance comparison calculator, but it's also the best way to compare any number of alternative investment vehicles, such as mutual funds that have different characteristics (loads, commissions, taxes, 12b-1 fees, and different dividend and capital gains distributions).

You just input 5-10 numbers on the "investment," the ending year's market values on the cash value life policy from an insurance contract "ledger" provided from an insurance salesperson. Then input the annual terms costs provided from a term life insurance ledger, and it shows the investment balance at the end of every year for both the cash value policy and alternative investment (and then it makes a graph).

This life insurance calculator is unique because it accurately determines the balance of investment vehicles by considering taxes on the annual realized capital gains, original basis, and the accumulated unrealized capital gains.

"Buy term and invest the difference" is just one of many functions of the Investment Comparator. All other information (demo, prices, etc.), is on the Investment Comparitor page.

All of the assumptions in the demos are that the insured investor does not die until after age 100. Obviously, if one were to pass away, then the life insurance strategy would win (especially in the early years).

VUL stands for Variable Universal Life Insurance, which has been state of the art in whole life insurance for over two decades. The variable part allows one to invest in things like mutual funds and universal means that it's flexible in many ways.

Term life insurance does not have a "savings account" associated with it, so you're just buying pure life insurance. The most efficient form of term was ART (Annually Renewable Term), but life insurance companies rarely sell that anymore because it doesn't make enormous gouging profits for them. Now it's all Level Term.

The great debate has been which performs best after one considers everything in great detail. The life insurance industry has led everyone to believe that VUL will always beat everything else because of all of the wonderful "tax advantages." It shouldn't be a mystery why they do that. They were able to get away with it before we made the one and only investment software that does the analysis properly.

But when one does the analysis correctly, accounting for all of the details, the strategy of buying term life insurance and investing the difference into no-load mutual funds always wins over buying any form of whole life insurance (we rarely say always, because this whole biz is a gray area, but this is a case where we're confident that no VUL can win. We know because the second demo uses the very best VUL, and it too is not even close).

Also, as Jordan points out, there are many tricks one can do with life insurance to even the playing field.

The reason this is the only life insurance calculator that can do this tedious job, is because keeping track of basis is extremely difficult. But once one can program that, then the bottom line is that the more you correctly meticulously account for ALL of the details, the more it's obvious that term and mutual fund will blow away whole life so bad that there should be a law!

Personal Finance Software Modules

Fully Integrated Financial Planning Software

Menu of Retirement Planning Software

Asset Allocation Overview with Historical Portfolio Returns

Comprehensive Asset Allocation Calculator

Asset Allocation Models with Historical Investment Returns

Monthly Updated Mutual Fund Picks

TVM Financial Tools

Free Personal Budget Software

Financial Planning Fact Finders

Investment Policy Statement Software

Bond Calculators

Investment Software for Comparing 23 Methods of Investing

Life Insurance Calculator

Real Estate Software

Net Worth Calculator

College Savings Calculator

Money eBook

Financial Planning Seminar

Financial Planning Marketing

Variable Annuity Tutorial and Optimizer

Services

Fee-only Consulting for Consumers, Investors, Financial Planners, and Expert Witness. Second Opinions for as little as $10 on Variable Universal / Whole Life Insurance and Annuity Recommendations

Building Custom Investment Benchmark Portfolios

Financial Planner Directory

How to Become Your Own RIA

Coaching for Financial Planners

Buy or Sell an Investment Management or Financial Planning Practice

Asset Allocation for 401(k) / 403(b) and Similar Retirement Plans

© Copyright 1997-2010 Tools For Money, All Rights Reserved